Guides  /  impact measurement

Logic models and social return on investment

A logic model sets out how an activity is supposed to produce a result. SROI puts a money value on that result and divides by what it cost. One is a planning tool that costs nothing and prevents most evaluation problems. The other produces a single memorable ratio that is far more sensitive to your assumptions than to your programme. This guide covers both, with the arithmetic shown.

Elaine Halliburton Written and reviewed by Elaine Halliburton, Professor of Applied Statistics
Updated 4 November 202613 min read
What is a logic model and how does it relate to SROI?

A logic model is a one-page chain from inputs to activities to outputs to outcomes to impact. It forces you to state what you expect to change and how, which is what makes an evaluation possible later. SROI takes the outcomes from that chain, assigns each a financial proxy, subtracts what would have happened anyway, discounts future years, and divides the total by the investment. The output is a ratio such as 9:1. The logic model is the prerequisite; without one, SROI is valuing outcomes nobody agreed to in advance.

Running 40,000 draws, with deadweight uniform between 15% and 50%, attribution between 10% and 35%, displacement between 5% and 20%, drop-off between 15% and 45% and the proxy between £9,000 and £15,000:

median 7.84 : 1
5th pct 5.08 : 1
95th pct 11.77 : 1
P(SROI > 5 : 1) = 96%
P(SROI > 10 : 1) = 18%

"We are 96% confident the return exceeds 5:1, under stated assumption ranges" is a claim that survives questioning. "9.31:1" does not, and the second statement is the one that gets printed.

The structure

The chain, and the step everyone skips

StageWhat it isExample
InputsWhat you put in£120,000, four staff, premises
ActivitiesWhat you doWeekly employability sessions, one-to-one coaching
OutputsWhat you produce, counted240 people attended, 1,100 sessions delivered
OutcomesWhat changes for them85 people in work six months later
ImpactThe change you causedThe portion of those 85 attributable to you

The skipped step is between outcomes and impact. Most reports stop at outcomes and present them as impact. The 85 people in work is an outcome. How many of those 85 would have found work without you is the question that turns it into impact, and it is the question the whole discipline exists to answer.

The assumptions column

A good logic model has a column most templates omit: what has to be true for each arrow to hold. "Attendance leads to improved confidence" assumes the sessions address confidence, that people attend enough of them, and that confidence is what was limiting them. Writing those down turns a diagram into something testable, and it is where an evaluator will start.

The most common confusion

Outputs are not outcomes

Funders ask for outcomes and receive outputs, reliably and almost universally.

OutputCorresponding outcome
240 people attended a course85 are in work six months later
1,200 leaflets distributedScreening uptake rose in the target group
50 staff trainedPractice changed in the way the training intended
A helpline answered 3,000 callsCallers resolved the problem they rang about

The left column is within your control and easy to count. The right requires following people after they leave, which costs money and sometimes produces unwelcome answers. That asymmetry is why output reporting persists.

The practical test: if the number would be the same whether or not the programme worked, it is an output.

Measurement

Choosing indicators that survive scrutiny

✓Define it before you start. "In work" means what exactly: any paid hours, sixteen hours a week, sustained for three months? Decide in advance, because deciding afterwards invites the definition that flatters the result.
✓Prefer validated instruments. A published wellbeing scale carries a known reliability and lets you compare with other studies. A bespoke five-question survey carries neither.
✓Collect a baseline. Without a before measurement there is no change to report, only a level. This is the most common irreversible mistake in programme evaluation.
✓Plan for attrition. Follow-up response rates of 40% to 60% are normal, and the people you lose differ systematically from those you keep. That is self-selection operating at the exit rather than the entrance.
✓Limit the number. Six indicators measured properly beat twenty measured partially, and fewer indicators means fewer chances to find a difference by accident.

Monetisation

What SROI adds, and what it costs you

SROI converts outcomes into money so that unlike things can be added together and compared with the investment. The appeal is obvious: a single number any funder understands.

Four adjustments stand between the raw outcome and the credited impact, and they are the substance of the method.

AdjustmentQuestion it answersTypical range
DeadweightHow much would have happened anyway?20–50%
AttributionHow much is down to other organisations?10–40%
DisplacementDid the benefit simply move from elsewhere?0–20%
Drop-offHow fast does the benefit fade?10–50% per year

Each is an estimate. None is observable. Together they usually remove half the headline value, and the figure you choose for each one moves the final ratio more than anything your programme actually did.

Worked example one

Calculating an SROI ratio

An employability programme costing £120,000 supports 85 people into work. The financial proxy is £12,000 per person per year, combining benefits no longer claimed and additional earnings.

Step 1. Gross outcome value

85 × £12,000 = £1,020,000 in year one

Step 2. Apply the three reducing adjustments

Deadweight 30%, attribution 20%, displacement 10%. They multiply rather than add.

(1 − 0.30) × (1 − 0.20) × (1 − 0.10) = 0.504

Only 50.4% of the gross value is credited to the programme. Year one impact is £514,080.

Step 3. Project forward with drop-off

The benefit fades at 25% a year over a three year horizon.

Step 4. Discount to present value

At the Green Book rate of 3.5%.

YearImpactDiscount factorPresent value
1£514,0800.9662£496,696
2£385,5600.9335£359,924
3£289,1700.9019£260,815
Total present value£1,117,435

Step 5. The ratio

SROI = £1,117,435 / £120,000 = 9.31 : 1

£9.31 of social value for every £1 invested. That is the number that will appear in the annual report, and on its own it is close to meaningless. The next section shows why.

Worked example two

The same programme, three ratios

Keep the cost, the 85 people and the £12,000 proxy exactly as they are. Change only the three judgement calls.

Assumption setDeadweightAttributionDisplacementSROI
Optimistic15%10%5%13.43 : 1
Middle30%20%10%9.31 : 1
Cautious50%35%20%4.80 : 1

Identical programme, identical outcomes, identical cost. The ratio ranges by a factor of nearly three, and every one of those assumption sets is defensible.

The horizon matters more than the judgement calls

The table above varies deadweight, attribution and displacement. Those are the three adjustments SROI guidance tells you to think about, so they get the attention. Two other choices move the number further and are usually made without comment.

Variation from the published casePresent valueSROI
1 year only£496,6964.14 : 1
2 years£856,6207.14 : 1
3 years, as published£1,117,4359.31 : 1
5 years£1,443,38512.03 : 1
10 years£1,731,77914.43 : 1

Changing nothing but the horizon moves the ratio from 4.14 to 14.43, a wider span than the whole optimistic-to-cautious range in the previous table. Nobody audits a horizon, because it looks like a technical parameter rather than a judgement.

The discount rate, by contrast, barely matters over a short horizon.

no discounting: £1,188,810 → 9.91 : 1
3.5% Green Book: £1,117,435 → 9.31 : 1
6%: £1,070,921 → 8.92 : 1

A full percentage point of discount rate is worth less than four months of horizon. Arguing about the discount rate while leaving the horizon unstated is the wrong way round, and it happens often.

What this means for how you use the number

An SROI ratio is not a measurement of a programme. It is a measurement of a programme plus a set of judgements, and the judgements carry more weight than the evidence. Two charities doing identical work can honestly report 5:1 and 13:1. Comparing published ratios between organisations is therefore meaningless unless both used the same assumptions, which they almost never do.

The remedy is not to abandon the method. It is to publish the sensitivity range rather than the point estimate, and to state every assumption with its source. An SROI reported as "between 4.8:1 and 13.4:1 depending on attribution assumptions, with 9.3:1 as our central estimate" is honest and still useful. A bare 9.3:1 is neither.

The weakest link

Financial proxies

Every outcome has to become a pound figure before it can enter the calculation. For some that is straightforward. For most it is not.

OutcomeProxy approachConfidence
Moved into employmentBenefits saved plus earnings gainedReasonable, both observable
Avoided a hospital admissionNational reference cost per admissionReasonable, published
Improved wellbeingWellbeing valuation from national datasetsContested, wide range
Increased confidenceCost of a comparable course, or stated preferenceWeak, largely arbitrary
Stronger community tiesVarious, none satisfactoryVery weak

The pattern is unavoidable: the outcomes that matter most to the people served are the hardest to value, and the values assigned to them are the least defensible. A programme whose main benefit is confidence or connection will have an SROI built mostly on contested proxies.

How much the proxy itself is worth

The published example values moving into employment at £12,000 a person. That figure is a choice, and it scales the whole result linearly.

Proxy per personPresent valueSROI
£9,000£838,0766.98 : 1
£10,500£977,7558.15 : 1
£12,000£1,117,4359.31 : 1
£13,500£1,257,11410.48 : 1
£15,000£1,396,79411.64 : 1

A quarter either way on one proxy moves the headline by more than two points. Because the relationship is linear, the ratio is only ever as defensible as the proxy, which is the argument for citing the source of every proxy and reporting the range the source itself gives.

One figure worth computing and almost never published: the value at which the programme stops washing its face.

SROI reaches 1 : 1 at a proxy of about £1,290 per person

The programme would have to be worth less than a ninth of the assumed figure before it stopped returning more than it cost. That is a far more robust claim than 9.31 : 1, and for most audiences it is the more persuasive one.

The HM Treasury Green Book and the Social Value Bank are the usual UK sources. Using a published proxy and citing it is far stronger than deriving your own, even when the published figure is imperfect, because it is transparent and comparable.

Doing it

Doing it in practice

Spreadsheet, and why that is the right answer

SROI is arithmetic, not statistics. A spreadsheet with one row per outcome and columns for quantity, proxy, deadweight, attribution, displacement, drop-off and discount factor is the standard approach, and it has a real advantage: every assumption is visible in a cell that a sceptical reader can change.

Build the sensitivity analysis into the same sheet. Three columns of assumptions, three ratios, no extra work.

R, for the parts that are statistical

The outcome measurement underneath SROI is where statistics belongs.

t.test(post, pre, paired = TRUE) # did the outcome change
DescTools::BinomCI(85, 240, method = "wilson") # proportion into work, with CI
MatchIt::matchit(treated ~ age + prior_benefit, data = d) # a comparison group

That last one matters most. Deadweight is usually guessed; matching against a comparison group estimates it instead. If you can obtain any comparison data at all, the single largest source of uncertainty in the whole model becomes measurable.

Monte Carlo, if the audience is sophisticated

Rather than three scenarios, draw each assumption from a plausible distribution a few thousand times and report the resulting range of ratios. Fifty lines of R. It turns the sensitivity question from three hand-picked cases into a proper distribution, and it is increasingly expected by larger funders.

Keep the model and the report separate

The spreadsheet should contain every assumption, its source and its rationale, and should be available on request. The published report should contain the central estimate, the range, and the three or four assumptions that drive it. Mixing the two produces a report nobody reads and a model nobody can audit.

Avoid these

Six mistakes that cost you credibility

MistakeWhy it matters
Reporting outputs as outcomes240 people attended is not 85 people in work. If the number would be identical whether or not the programme worked, it is an output.
Publishing a single ratioThe same programme yields 4.8:1 or 13.4:1 on defensible assumptions. A point estimate implies precision the method cannot deliver.
Guessing deadweightIt is usually the largest adjustment and the one most often picked to suit. A comparison group turns it from a guess into an estimate.
Comparing ratios between organisationsDifferent proxies, different assumptions, different horizons. Two identical programmes can differ threefold.
No baselineWithout a before measurement there is no change to value. This cannot be fixed retrospectively.
Extending the horizon to improve the ratioFive years instead of three raises the number and lowers the credibility. Justify the horizon from the outcome, not the result.
Can a funder check the number you are about to publish?

An SROI ratio is a programme plus a set of judgement calls, and the horizon alone can move it from 4:1 to 14:1. Send the model and you get a sensitivity range rather than a point estimate, with every assumption sourced.

See statistical consultancy
Elaine HalliburtonElaine HalliburtonProfessor of Applied Statistics

Writing it up

How to report it

✓The logic model itself, including the assumptions column.
✓Each outcome with how it was measured, the baseline, and the follow-up rate.
✓Every proxy with its source and its value, in a table.
✓All four adjustments with the reasoning for each figure, not just the figure.
✓The time horizon and discount rate, with a justification for the horizon.
✓A sensitivity range, given at least as much prominence as the central ratio.

The sentence that does the work: "Our central estimate is £9.31 of social value per £1 invested. Under more cautious assumptions about deadweight and attribution the figure is £4.80, and under optimistic assumptions £13.43. The range reflects judgement about what would have happened anyway, which we have not been able to measure directly."

Common questions

Frequently asked questions

What is a logic model?

A one-page chain showing how inputs become activities, activities become outputs, outputs become outcomes and outcomes become impact. Its value is that it forces you to state in advance what you expect to change and why, which is what makes evaluation possible later. The best versions add a column recording what must be true for each step to hold.

What is the difference between outputs and outcomes?

Outputs are what you produced and can count, such as 240 attendances. Outcomes are what changed for people, such as 85 in work six months later. The practical test is whether the number would be the same regardless of whether the programme worked. If it would, it is an output.

How do you calculate SROI?

Multiply the outcome quantity by a financial proxy, reduce it for deadweight, attribution and displacement, project forward with an annual drop-off, discount each year to present value, sum them, and divide by the investment. In the worked example this gave £1,117,435 of present value against £120,000 invested, a ratio of 9.31 to 1."

What is deadweight?

The share of the outcome that would have occurred without your programme. It is typically the largest adjustment, often 20% to 50%, and the hardest to establish. Guessing it is normal practice and the main weakness of most SROI studies; a matched comparison group turns the guess into an estimate.

Can I compare my SROI with another organisation's?

No, unless both used identical proxies, adjustments and time horizons, which is very rare. The same programme with the same outcomes and cost produces ratios between 4.8:1 and 13.4:1 depending on defensible assumption choices, so a comparison between organisations mostly compares their assumptions.

What discount rate should I use?

3.5% is the HM Treasury Green Book rate for UK public sector appraisal and is the conventional choice. State it explicitly, along with the time horizon, since both materially affect the result and a longer horizon always flatters it.

Is SROI worth doing?

It is worth doing properly or not at all. Done with a logic model, measured outcomes, a baseline, published proxies and an honest sensitivity range, it is a useful way to compare options within one organisation. Done as a single ratio derived from estimated adjustments, it is a marketing number, and funders increasingly recognise the difference.